Updated: On Tuesday, longtime criminal defense attorney Charles Murphy gave up his Illinois law license.
Before the end of the week he was sitting stone-faced in a federal courtroom in Chicago full of his supporters, awaiting sentence in a $9.2 million mortgage-fraud case.
U.S. District Judge Ronald Guzman gave the 65-year-old ex-attorney six years. Prosecutors had sought more than double that amount, contending that Murphy was a key figure in a flipping scheme. It involved the sale of 40 homes in low-income South Side neighborhoods at inflated prices between 2002 and 2006, often to so-called straw buyers who weren’t qualified or willing to actually make the loan payments, according to the Chicago Tribune:
Lawyer sentenced to 6 years in mortgage fraud
The sentencing of Charles Murphy started with a question that might have been on the minds of anyone who has followed the career of the veteran Chicago criminal defense attorney.
“I wonder what the heck Mr. Murphy is doing here?” Assistant U.S. Attorney Brian Netols said as the defendant awaited his fate on federal wire and mail fraud convictions for financing fraudulent real estate transactions.
U.S. District Judge Ronald Guzman sentenced Murphy to six years in prison, less than half the maximum sought by prosecutors.
Prosecutors said Murphy played an integral role in the $9.2 million scheme, in which about 40 residences in economically depressed areas on the South Side were bought and then resold at fraudulently inflated prices from 2002 to 2006. Four others also were convicted in the scheme, which relied on straw purchasers.
Murphy, 65, sat stone-faced in a federal courtroom packed with colleagues, friends and family, who had gathered to support him.
For years he was a familiar face at the Cook County Criminal Court Building at 26th Street and California Avenue, where he worked as a public defender before entering private practice.
After Netols asked why Murphy got himself involved in the fraud scheme, he answered the question in a word himself: greed. Netols also took issue with how the scheme targeted an already beleaguered community.
“He didn’t choose to flip houses in his Mount Greenwood neighborhood,” the prosecutor said. “He went over to Englewood. … As an experienced criminal defense attorney, he had all the evidence at the first transaction that he committed fraud. And he went for it.”
Murphy’s lawyer, Susan Shatz, spoke of his military record — he volunteered for the Marines during the Vietnam War — as well as his age and diagnosis of prostate cancer.
She also mentioned the numerous letters, including several from Cook County judges, that sought leniency.
“I would like to add my voice to the letters,” Shatz said. “I clerked for him myself. Mr. Murphy is a great mentor. He is a great friend. He helped many people, including me.”
Shatz contended that Murphy was duped by one of his co-defendants. She portrayed Robert Brunt, who was sentenced to 12 1/2 years this week for his role, as a slippery character who came to Murphy seeking a loan for his business and then drew him into the crooked scheme.
“Anybody can be conned by a con man,” she said.
In court papers, prosecutors argued that Murphy was the more sophisticated of the two, noting Brunt’s limited education.
Murphy addressed the judge briefly. Like the attorney he was until Tuesday, when he surrendered his law license, Murphy first asked to correct the record — Shatz had misstated the titles of his military medals. Murphy then thanked his wife.
“Whatever the outcome, I do understand I am fortunate in one regard — the support of my wife of 45 years,” he said. “Thank you, Patricia.”
Guzman said he considered Murphy’s age one of the “heaviest factors” weighing in favor of a shorter sentence. The judge seemed moved by Murphy’s military record as well.
“Clearly that has to count for something,” he said.
But Guzman pointed out the local and national impact of mortgage fraud schemes, particularly those that divert money set aside to help people with lower incomes purchase a home, as in this case.
In the end, Guzman was left questioning how Murphy joined in the fraud scheme after so many years in the criminal justice field.
“He had an education, a profession. He had a career. He earned a substantial income,” the judge said. “One must be left wondering how he found his way here.”
Another attorney who is a co-defendant in the case, 50-year-old John Farano, was sentenced to nine years on Wednesday:
Palos Park lawyer sentenced for mortgage fraud
A Palos Park attorney has been sentenced to nine years in prison and ordered to pay more than $1.3 million in restitution following his conviction last year for taking part in a multimillion-dollar mortgage fraud scheme, the U.S. attorney’s office in Chicago said Thursday.
John Farano, whose law license has been suspended, was also ordered to forfeit more than $2.3 million, according to a news release from the U.S. attorney’s office.
Farano, 50, and three other people were convicted of multiple counts of mail and wire fraud last December following a nine-week trial. The four netted about $5.45 million in fraudulently obtained mortgage loans, and the scheme involved paying kickbacks to a nonprofit organization to obtain some of the properties at a discount from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, the U.S. attorney’s office said.
The scheme involved at least 40 residential properties, primarily located in Chicago’s Englewood community, according to the news release.
Farano and another attorney, Charles Murphy, of Chicago, put up money to buy residences knowing they’d earn a profit from the fraudulently obtained mortgages, the U.S. attorney said.
Farano, who was sentenced Wednesday, was convicted of four counts of mail and wire fraud and five counts of theft of government funds, and is scheduled to begin serving his sentence Sept. 10, the U.S. attorney said.
During the trial, federal prosecutors said the scheme involved buying homes that needed extensive repairs and which were located in economically-depressed neighborhoods. Homes were bought using straw buyers and properties were resold at grossly inflated prices, often with little actual repair work being done on the homes, the government said.
Others sentenced Wednesday were Robert Brunt, of Chicago, who was president of Genesis Investment Group, and Tracey Scullark, of Chicago, a sales agent for Genesis. Brunt was sentenced to 121/2 years in prison and Scullark received 61/2 years. They were ordered to pay more than $1.6 million in restitution and forfeit $4.2 million in proceeds.
Farano — whose firm concentrates in criminal defense, personal injury and real estate — handled real estate closings in the fraudulent deals for Genesis, the government said. The lawyer also operated Big Dog Holdings, BD Financial Group and Capital Acquisitions, which provided the upfront money to buy the distressed properties, the government said.
An earlier Chicago Tribune article published when Murphy and Farano were convicted by a federal jury in December of five counts of mail and wire fraud explains the claimed scheme:
Lawyer found guilty in home mortgage fraud scheme
A federal jury convicted a veteran Chicago criminal-defense lawyer Thursday of taking part in a $9 million mortgage fraud scheme that took advantage of unqualified home buyers in economically depressed neighborhoods in the city.
Charles Murphy, 65, was convicted of five counts of mail and wire fraud in U.S. District Judge Ronald Guzman’s courtroom in the Dirksen U.S. Courthouse, according to the U.S. attorney’s office in Chicago.
Murphy and three others allegedly acquired at least 40 residences — often homes in need of extensive repairs — and quickly resold them at inflated prices.
Murphy, an attorney since 1974, and John Farano, 49, a lawyer from Palos Park, allegedly had financed the purchases. Robert Brunt, 45, and Tracey Scullark, 43, both of Chicago, allegedly recruited unqualified buyers by enticing them with false sales offers and promises of prompt repairs and renovations, according to court documents.
Prosecutors alleged that Murphy and others urged buyers to sign closing documents they had never seen and falsely inflated the amount of money posted by buyers for down payments, making it more likely lenders would approve loans.
The scheme allegedly took place from 2002 to 2006 and defrauded banks, mortgage lenders and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
Farano, Brunt and Scullark were each convicted Thursday of multiple counts, while another defendant, Douglas Blanchard, was acquitted on the lone mail fraud count he faced.
Two others, Walter Jackson, 38, and Armani D’Aifallah, 40, both of Chicago, pleaded guilty in 2009 and testified for the prosecution at the trial, according to the U.S. attorney’s office.
Prosecutors are seeking forfeiture of at least $4.2 million from those convicted in the scheme.
Prosecutors said co-defendants worked together to sell homes purchased by Murphy and Farano to unqualified buyers. Lenders were then persuaded to grant mortgages based on loan paperwork that contained false information, such as inflated down payment amounts. The homes often needed work, and buyers were promised renovations that didn’t occur, according to court documents. Farano served as a closing attorney on some of the fraudulent deals.
Meanwhile, buyers were persuaded to sign on in order to get no-money-down or cash-back-at-closing deals, explains a press release (PDF) from the U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois. It notes that Farano was found guilty of four counts of mail and wire fraud and five counts of theft of government funds, but acquitted on three mail and wire fraud counts.
The Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission website shows that Farano’s law license was suspended on an interim basis pending further proceedings, on June 26.